I just came across another DnD podcast Acquisition's Inc
It is funnt...though not as funny as Critical Hits,
I would LOVE a non-canon Critical Hits/Acqusition's Inc. crossover/battle.
Eight players, 3 GMs. It would be madness.
You could ask Scott Kurtz the next time you see him.
I have to disagree on the humor aspect. I found the PennyArcade/PVP podcasts to be far and away more humorous. I found myself cracking up almost the whole time. But that's to be expected. With the exception of Chris Perkins, who actually had some great lines, theses guys are professional humorists. Wheaton maybe not as much, but he's still a professional actor.
I think the critical hit podcast is great, it provides a much clearer and more interesting narrative, explains the game better, and achieves moments of dramatic tension, which Acquisition's never comes close too. But for the most part the humorous part of critical hit is Torq followed Rodrigo getting pissed at Matthew. For straight up humor there is no comparison. I mean Penny Arcade wins hands down just using Jim Darkmagic. The name alone wins it for them.
Also I would love to see some sort of cross over. If Chris Perkins could guest DM and we could see Rodrigo as a player, that would be what I would most like to see.
Last thing, Chris Perkins did a similar game with the guys from Robot Chicken. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJN1JvnRGWE
It's also up on the D&D podcast on Itunes