
With the buzz about the plot of Captain America being released, the comments have been flying as to who will play the role of Steve Rogers. We’ve taken your nominations, now it’s time to fight it out, and let you decide who would be the best Captain America in the upcoming movie.
Related posts
23 Responses to “Major Spoilers Poll of the Week: Casting Captain America”
Leave a Reply
- Review: The Flash – Rebirth #5 (of 6)
- Review: Dr. Horrible
- Review: Disney Christmas Classics
- Review: Batman #693
- Review: S.W.O.R.D. #1
- Review: Nola #1
- Review: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly #5
- Review: Batgirl #4
- Review: Green Lantern Corps #42
- Dueling Reviews: Zorro #17
- Review: Locke & Key: Crown of Shadows #1
- Review: Immortal Weapons #4 (of 5)
- Review: The Great Ten #1 (of 10)
- Review: Blackbeard, Legend of the Pyrate King #2
- Review: Batman/Doc Savage Special #1
- MSP#152: The Truth about Doctor True, and Other Amazin’ Tales
- Critical Hit #21 – How the other half live – Part 2
- MSP#151: Interview: Matt Sturges
- MSP#150: Yeah, we can’t believe it either…
- Critical Hit #20: How the Other Half Live
- MSP#149: Interview: Caleb Monroe
- MSP#148: The Super Future Friends Pay a Visit
- MSP#147: Favorite Doctor Who Episodes
- Critical Hit #19: Adventurer’s Vault 2
- MSP#146: Parker: The Hunter, can’t lose
- Critical Hit #18: Aboard the Airship!
- Major Spoilers Podcast #145: Doctor Who is Missing
- Thanks again! Critical Hit, hits front page of iTunes Podcasts
- Thank you for making Critical Hit, a hit!
- Major Spoilers Desktop Background…

Action Figures Animation Archie Comics art Art Appreciation Moment of the Day Avengers Batman Battlestar Galactica Betty Boom Studios Buffy the Vampire Slayer Captain America cartoon Civil War comic convention Contest Cosplay CW Dark Horse Comics DC Diamond Comic Distributors Diamond Select Toys Disney Doctor Who DVD Dynamite Entertainment Fan Film Fantastic Four Featured Final Crisis From the Editor Gaming Green Lantern Heroes Hero History Hulk Humor IDW Publishing Image Comics Interviews Invincible Iron Man Justice League of America Legion of Super Heroes Major Spoilers Major Spoilers Podcast Mark Waid Marvel Movies Music NBC New Comic Releases New York Comic Con Oni Press Podcast Poll Press Release Preview Radical Publishing Red Sonja Reprint Retro Review Review san diego Secret Invasion Skrullapalooza Smallville Sneak Peek Solicitations Spider-Man Star Trek Star Wars statues Superman Television The Dark Knight The Darkness Thor Top Cow Toys Trade Paperback Trailer Transformers Variant Veronica Video Warner Bros. Watchmen webcomic web comics Witchblade Wolverine Wonder Woman X-Men Zenescope Entertainment Zombies










Matt Damon as Cap!
Brad Pitt as Thor!
‘Nuff Said!
It’s a sad day when Fred Savage is beating Leo DiCaprio. Puberty was the worse thing to happen to him…
What? No John Barrowman? Come on, the rumors out there, let us vote on it! No love for Torchwood?
Real World
———————–
Brad Pitt beats Damon for me, why?
Well he is older for one thing, yeah i know he has to play a young recrut/artist dude…BUT you have to remember that he through the Avengers movie has to boss around Norton, Downey (Older dudes) and whomever, and Damon really doesnt really look as intelligent or as much of an authority as Pitt..Besides Pitt looks much more like Cap already. Im also saying Pitt as to in my mind keep him from being Thor…he would do a horrible Thor,(well no horrible but below what could be achieved)
as i already said they need a big (preferibly Scandinavian) outsider of sorts to play Thor IMHO.
In my dreams
———————————–
NATHAN MOTHERFUCKING FILLION!
He was born for the part and already played it to perfection in Firefly–The man is cap, looks cap, radiates cap and sounds cap. THIS IS THE ULTIMATE TRUTH!
Unfortunately though i live in the realworld, and thats what i vote by :(
WHY WONT MY DREAMS EVER COME TRUE !!!!
Gooooooooooooooooo Titan!!! (Heh. I was honestly stunned to see Mike O’Hearn on this list. Possibly the only time he’ll ever be mentioned with DiCrappio and Matt Dumbhead.)
Matt Damon can do all the awesome things in Bourne. He IS Cap!
why the hell isnt bob saget in that damn poll. saget=best captain america ever!!!
nice pit stain on the main cap pick
I voted Nathan Fillion. Not because I’m a fan or anything but what I did know of him was that he is Canadian. A Canadian as Captain America. I find that hilarious.
It’s matt all the way for me. I’ve always considered Steve Rogers/Captain america to be two seperate kinds of people and an actor needs to be able to play both. Steve Rogers is supposed to be this slightly naive and kind of weak patriotic young guy who gets infused with the power of the super soildier serum in order to do uncle sams bidding. In the earlier avengers stories (not to mention the ultimates) Steve has some trouble readjusting to the “new world” that he wakes up to after being frozen, I think matt could play the “naive/idealistic guy in a complicated world” quite well…and brad pitt is too macho for the role, would work great as thor though…
I am really surprised that Thomas Jane isn’t higher on the list. Cap is just so iconic, that I’d prefer to not to have such a famous actor play him. I don’t want to look at Cap and think, “hey, there’s Matt Damon.” And frankly, I think Jane looks the part more than anyone on the list too. Nathan Fillion just lacks a certain Cap quality that I just can’t put my finger on right now.
I vote none of the above. Matt Keeslar from “The Middleman” is my choice.
Where’s Matthew McConaughey?
@Eddie
Oh how i hope you are being sarcastic..
They could appeal to the female demographic with a shirtless-Cap if they went with McConaughey
McConaughey would have loved to land the role of Bruce Banner, all of that shirt tearing…
There is something decidedly wrong with that man though.
I’d like to see Paul Walker in the role, though McConaughey would be acceptable.
Matt Damon?
Anyone else watch Team America?
I haven’t been able to look at Matt Damon without yelling his name and cracking up ever since that movie…
I vote Daniel Craig. I have since I left the theater after Casino Royale. I don’t care where he’s from he can cover his accent, he has the acting chops, looks and the physical presence. Plus he could help out selling tickets to Europe. If that’s a real concern.
At the risk of being flamed off this site, I will say that I thought McConaughey would have been fine for the role. I think people get his personal life/airhead roles confused with his actual acting ability. I mean, if you look back at “A Time To Kill” or “U-571″, he certainly didn’t embarass himself. And he’s obviously fit enough for the physical demands of the role. He’s definitely a hell of a lot better choice than John Cena, whose name I keep seeing on message boards everywhere. Out of this list, though, I’m voting for Thomas Jane, even though he already did the Punisher thing. And, for the record, I don’t even know the the hell Nathan Fillion is.
I am sooo against Matt Damon getting the role, since I have heard rumors he could be in that Green Arrow Prison movie.
Eric Dane. He is the only guy who can carry the role.