![]()
Given 15 minutes, Batman and MacGyver can make a nuclear fusion reactor out of bubblegum and bailing wire. But given only 10 minutes, who would win in building something practical to get them out of a tight fix?
Let the Battle of the Brains Begin!
Related posts
21 Responses to “Major Spoilers Poll of the Week!”
Leave a Reply
- Review: The Flash – Rebirth #5 (of 6)
- Review: Dr. Horrible
- Review: Disney Christmas Classics
- Review: Batman #693
- Review: S.W.O.R.D. #1
- Review: Nola #1
- Review: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly #5
- Review: Batgirl #4
- Review: Green Lantern Corps #42
- Dueling Reviews: Zorro #17
- Review: Locke & Key: Crown of Shadows #1
- Review: Immortal Weapons #4 (of 5)
- Review: The Great Ten #1 (of 10)
- Review: Blackbeard, Legend of the Pyrate King #2
- Review: Batman/Doc Savage Special #1
- MSP#152: The Truth about Doctor True, and Other Amazin’ Tales
- Critical Hit #21 – How the other half live – Part 2
- MSP#151: Interview: Matt Sturges
- MSP#150: Yeah, we can’t believe it either…
- Critical Hit #20: How the Other Half Live
- MSP#149: Interview: Caleb Monroe
- MSP#148: The Super Future Friends Pay a Visit
- MSP#147: Favorite Doctor Who Episodes
- Critical Hit #19: Adventurer’s Vault 2
- MSP#146: Parker: The Hunter, can’t lose
- Critical Hit #18: Aboard the Airship!
- Major Spoilers Podcast #145: Doctor Who is Missing
- Thanks again! Critical Hit, hits front page of iTunes Podcasts
- Thank you for making Critical Hit, a hit!
- Major Spoilers Desktop Background…

Action Figures Animation Archie Comics art Art Appreciation Moment of the Day Avengers Batman Battlestar Galactica Betty Boom Studios Buffy the Vampire Slayer Captain America cartoon Civil War comic convention Contest Cosplay CW Dark Horse Comics DC Diamond Comic Distributors Diamond Select Toys Disney Doctor Who DVD Dynamite Entertainment Fan Film Fantastic Four Featured Final Crisis From the Editor Gaming Green Lantern Heroes Hero History Hulk Humor IDW Publishing Image Comics Interviews Invincible Iron Man Justice League of America Legion of Super Heroes Major Spoilers Major Spoilers Podcast Mark Waid Marvel Movies Music NBC New Comic Releases New York Comic Con Oni Press Podcast Poll Press Release Preview Radical Publishing Red Sonja Reprint Retro Review Review san diego Secret Invasion Skrullapalooza Smallville Sneak Peek Solicitations Spider-Man Star Trek Star Wars statues Superman Television The Dark Knight The Darkness Thor Top Cow Toys Trade Paperback Trailer Transformers Variant Veronica Video Warner Bros. Watchmen webcomic web comics Witchblade Wolverine Wonder Woman X-Men Zenescope Entertainment Zombies










MacGyver seems to have an intuitive aptitude that few can match. It is the same reason I normally vote Tony Stark over Batman in such situations.
But in the case of MacGyver vs Batman I am going to give this to Bruce. The margin is only because Bruce seems to be versed in a wider variety of sciences and has a genius that Tony can match but I think outstrips Angus MacGyver.
I dunno, I’m going with Angus MaGyver on this one. His improvisational skills are unmatched. He ALWAYS uses what he finds lying around, plus his name is Angus, which is very cool.
I’m gonna have to go with McGyver on this. I don’t know the character very well, but there’s one thing that just gives him the upper hand : using bubblegum and a rubber band to build a thingy that saves the day ? That HIS schtick.
I know Batman has the awesome power of convenient writing (”I am Batman. And I can breathe in space”) and can defeat even TEH DEVIL if he has time to prepare, but that’s not all there is to him. Batman is also the master detective, the master strategist, the martial artist, the science whiz and the big bad scary mofo.
He’s very polyvalent and very good at everything he does, but McGyver ? Building implausible day-saving thingies is ALL he does. It’s his ultimate specialty, and that’s why he’s probably the best at it.
I am apparently not wired to vote anything other than Batman… Really though where Angus may be the classic “improv superhero” Bats is still more talented in that regard…Its one of those (as Matthew put it) examples of it not being the same weightclass, league…heck not even the same ballgame.
Comicbooks do strive towards the extreme and Batman is a character of extremes.
So while Mac may be a god of improv he is still restricted to his medium and because of that he has yet to kill a “new god”.
People who are voting for Batman are blind. Batman doesn’t build anything; he has it built for him. Batman’s shtick is to come up with a plan in 10 min; not build anything. Building stuff is MacGyver’s shtick.
I don’t really think many situations come to mind when Bats has actually had something built to survive. Most of Batman’s strategies involve careful planning and using his equipment, but as far as inventing something on the spot? I can’t think of any examples of this.
I’ll go with McGyver.
Can someone give me an example of when Batman had to build something quickly to survive?
McGyver, because Batman’s a thinker not a tinker.
Will he may not have built anything batman gets my vote for his sheer amount of equipment. Anyone who has shark repellant on his belt for just such an occasion is my vote winner.
Although macguyver may get some credit for http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTWEh2mcdsg
Bat’s really isn’t the builder type, he’ll have a gizmo for all occasions (ie bat shark repellent) but really isn’t known for his ability to whip something out of nothing, (if by nothing you DON”T mean his utility belt).
Put The A-Team against MacGyver – that’s a mash up I’d watch!
lol, The A-Team vs Mcgyver someone said that earlier, I think Mcgyvver would win, only cause the A-Team would try to shoot at him, and like always, they miss. He’ll have more than 30 mins to build anything.
Well, it depends on where this predicament takes place.
On the scientificaly accurate world of McGyver (more or less accurate as MythBusters as shown) I’de give the win to McGyver, but if they’re facing trouble in the comic book world filled with magic, pseudo science and scifi Batman for the win!
I’m going to say McGyver. Batman would just beat the crap out of whatever was in his way and just be done with it, but the poll says he has to build something, to McGyver gets the edge.
Edge to the man with the better hair…McGyver!!!
If the competition was only about inventing stuff, then Angus would win – hands down. But if they were to go head-to-head arena style in an empty house, then…well…Batman would just rape Angus.
oh come on! This would’ve been a better question if it was Stark vs McGyver. Even then, I’ll still may pick McGyver over Stark because Stark may overthink it in 10 minutes.
Ol’ Batsy probably can build something on the fly to get him out of the jam, but he probably would not get into that jam in the first place(Batman without utility belt? how often does that happen)
BTW Batman has been seen tinkering with his own equipment…Technology foreign to earth, gizmos his enemies use…and Ive lost count of how many Antidotes he has made over the years. He has sabotaged tech, fiddled with the Mad Hatters chips and…My point is he IS a tinkerer..but not only that, his fields also expand beyond electronics, physics and chemistry (Which is what McGyver does)into stuff a bit more biological and medical.
I’m voting for MacGruber…(singing)MACGRUBER!
“Build something”? MacGyver! Batman would already have something in his “bottomless bat utility belt of holding”…
…thinking on this further, I think a better “building” battle would be between Mac and Fixer of the Thunderbolts (really liked that character during the Busiek/Nicieza run).
Mcgyver wins. He doesnt carry an arsenal or high tech weaponry or a state of the art costume, utility belt etc. Mcgyver wins.
Batman would already have it made