![]()
We’re almost done with the battle between the Watchmen and the characters that inspired them. This week it’s a battle of the faceless ones as The Question takes on Rorschach, and YOU, the Major Spoilers Legion, gets to decide who wins… and who ends up screaming to the doctor to give him back his face.
FIGHT!
Related posts

Add to favorites
9 Responses to “Major Spoilers Poll of the Week: Watching the Watchmen (and Their Counterparts)”
Leave a Reply
- Review: The Flash – Rebirth #5 (of 6)
- Review: Dr. Horrible
- Review: Disney Christmas Classics
- Review: Batman #693
- Review: S.W.O.R.D. #1
- Review: Nola #1
- Review: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly #5
- Review: Batgirl #4
- Review: Green Lantern Corps #42
- Dueling Reviews: Zorro #17
- Review: Locke & Key: Crown of Shadows #1
- Review: Immortal Weapons #4 (of 5)
- Review: The Great Ten #1 (of 10)
- Review: Blackbeard, Legend of the Pyrate King #2
- Review: Batman/Doc Savage Special #1
- MSP#152: The Truth about Doctor True, and Other Amazin’ Tales
- Critical Hit #21 – How the other half live – Part 2
- MSP#151: Interview: Matt Sturges
- MSP#150: Yeah, we can’t believe it either…
- Critical Hit #20: How the Other Half Live
- MSP#149: Interview: Caleb Monroe
- MSP#148: The Super Future Friends Pay a Visit
- MSP#147: Favorite Doctor Who Episodes
- Critical Hit #19: Adventurer’s Vault 2
- MSP#146: Parker: The Hunter, can’t lose
- Critical Hit #18: Aboard the Airship!
- Major Spoilers Podcast #145: Doctor Who is Missing
- Thanks again! Critical Hit, hits front page of iTunes Podcasts
- Thank you for making Critical Hit, a hit!
- Major Spoilers Desktop Background…

Action Figures Animation Archie Comics art Art Appreciation Moment of the Day Avengers Batman Battlestar Galactica Betty Boom Studios Buffy the Vampire Slayer Captain America cartoon Civil War comic convention Contest Cosplay CW Dark Horse Comics DC Diamond Comic Distributors Diamond Select Toys Disney Doctor Who DVD Dynamite Entertainment Fan Film Fantastic Four Featured Final Crisis From the Editor Gaming Green Lantern Heroes Hero History Hulk Humor IDW Publishing Image Comics Interviews Invincible Iron Man Justice League of America Legion of Super Heroes Major Spoilers Major Spoilers Podcast Mark Waid Marvel Movies Music NBC New Comic Releases New York Comic Con Oni Press Podcast Poll Press Release Preview Radical Publishing Red Sonja Reprint Retro Review Review san diego Secret Invasion Skrullapalooza Smallville Sneak Peek Solicitations Spider-Man Star Trek Star Wars statues Superman Television The Dark Knight The Darkness Thor Top Cow Toys Trade Paperback Trailer Transformers Variant Veronica Video Warner Bros. Watchmen webcomic web comics Witchblade Wolverine Wonder Woman X-Men Zenescope Entertainment Zombies








Rorschach may f- you up with righteous fury, but The Question was trained by Richard Dragon. You can’t beat the kung-fu… Plus, HE HAS NO FACE!
Question, mainly because of the JLU. Whose version was inspired by Rorschach, but Rorschach was inspired by the Question, so older man wins.
Who wins? Mr. A.
I say Question, he’s the original one.
In JLU he was great and so was his run in 52.
Rorschach is pretty effing cool, but I’m partial to The Question (as well as Renee Montoya) because of the 52 connection. :D
There’s no question here: Rorschach would lose in a fight.
As much as I want Rorschach to raise my children because I believe him to be a wonderful roll model, The question would kick his ass.
The Question was trained by a great martial artist in a wheelchair. Rory is a whatever goes retard stregnth kinda guy.
I voted for Rorschach, mainly because his character blew me away when I first read Watchmen. But The Question is also a good character. He was one of my faves in JLU (which version, admittedly, was based on RR), but I also liked him in Huntress: Cry for Blood.
It’s interesting to see that Watchmen has become so influential that the original Charleston characters are now often overshadowed and themselves influenced by the Watchmen chars.
I’m a huge fan of the Dennis O’Neill Question run. Watchmen is great. I do not like the Renee Montoya Question. Still, I voted for the Question anyway.