![]()
This week, we return to the battle between the characters from Alan Moore’s Watchmen series, and the original characters that inspired them. This week, it’s the battle of the ladies, as Silk Spectre wrestles with… well, there is no direct Charlton character that inspired Silk Spectre, but Alan Moore did say she is a cross between Phantom Lady and Black Canary. So, let’s go with Phantom Lady.
FIGHT
Related posts
10 Responses to “Major Spoiler Poll of the Week: Watchmen Smack Down Part 3”
Leave a Reply
- Critical Hit #40: CROSSOVER!
- Major Spoilers Podcast #187
- Major Spoilers Podcast #186: The Losers
- Critical Hit #39: Stop Loitering Around My Weasel Stand!
- Major Spoilers Podcast #185: Visual Plagiarism
- Major Spoilers Podcast #183: Podcast by Gaslight
- Critical Hit #38: The Mucus Men of Tuberville – or – You may think it’s funny, but it’s snot
- Major Spoilers Podcast #182: A World of Toys
- Major Spoilers Podcast #181: The Dark Phoenix Podcast
- Major Spoilers Podcast #180: This one time, at a M:TG Tournament…
- Critical Hit #37: Doom Comes to Tuberville
- Major Spoilers Podcast #179: The Podcast and Me
- Critical Hit #36: The Tower – Part 7
- Major Spoilers Podcast #178: How did YOU get into comics?
- Major Spoilers Podcast #177: Holy Terror, Batman!

Action Figures Amazing Spider-Man Animation Archie Comics Army of Darkness art Art Appreciation Moment of the Day Avengers Batman Battlestar Galactica Betty Blackest Night Bluewater Productions Boom Studios Buffy the Vampire Slayer Captain America cartoon cartoon network Civil War comic convention Contest Cosplay CW Dark Horse Comics DC Diamond Comic Distributors Diamond Select Toys Digital Comics Disney Doctor Who Dungeons And Dragons DVD Dynamite Entertainment Fan Film Fantastic Four Featured Final Crisis Flash Free Comic Book Day From the Editor Gaming Grant Morrison Green Lantern Heroes Hero History Holiday Hulk Humor IDW Publishing Image Comics Interviews Invincible Iron Man Justice League of America Legion of Super Heroes Major Spoilers Major Spoilers Podcast Mark Waid Marvel Merchandise Moonstone Books Movies Music NBC New Comic Releases New York Comic Con Oni Press Podcast Poll Press Release Preview Radical Publishing Red Sonja Reprint Retro Review Review Robin Rumor san diego Secret Invasion Skrullapalooza Smallville Sneak Peek Solicitations Spider-Man Star Trek Star Wars statues Superman Television The Boys The Dark Knight The Darkness Thor Top Cow Toys Trade Paperback Trailer Transformers Variant Veronica Video Warner Bros. Watchmen webcomic web comics Witchblade Wolverine Wonder Woman X-Men Zenescope Entertainment Zombies












Phantom Lady has powers, so it’s not really a fair fight now is it?
i voted for silk spectre because i don’t know the other one. on the other hand, she appear a lot more naked than silk spectre.
meh, screw hit, a hot chick is a hot chick, naked or not.
Going with Phantom Lady. She actually did more than whine and keep a human A- bomb “happy,” heroics- wise. And the costume… yeah… yeah, she gets my vote.
Phantom Lady hotness all the way. From her Golden Age beginnings right to today.
Dude- if PL can fight crime with those ginormous boobs, then you have to give her the win.
Silk for the win, prettier and as far as i can tell more badass….had it been Black Canary up there i might have voted differently.
I thought Spectre was inspired by Nightshade? Unless the timing of that is wrong, and if Moore himself says so it can’t really be denied…
Don’t know if you guys have read any of the Uncle Sam and the Freedom Fighters comics but Phanom Lady (Stormy Knight) is wayyy prettier then Spectre. She has a degree in quantum physics and her gantlets are powerful weapons that give her powers like Nightshade but based on light, she even has the power to teleport herself and the Fighters through a special dimension just like Nightshade.
Is this a pillow fight?
powers>no powers. i.e. phantom lady>silk spectre